Judicial Review
Comments
MAJORITY OPINION.-The Constitution grants the Supreme Court a Constitutional jurisdiction to hear and make determinations on the interpretation of legislation and its constitutionality.
1. In Part 1, Section 1(10)(1) "...[under official authority]" in and of itself unconstitutional. The Constitution in Article 8, Section 3(1) is clear: "breaking or breaching of any civil rights shall be considered perversion of rights..[]" regardless of capacity. Additionally, the Constitution in the same quoted provision doesn't require the breach to be intentional or reckless; any manner would be sufficient. Negligence of the law is no excuse.
2. Numerous provisions in the proposed amendment provide vague and broad language like "misbehavior", "unrelated to the emergency", "personal interest", etc that violates the Right to a Fair Trial under the Constitution. Laws dictate what a person is not allowed to do and should be clearly established. Failing to clearly outline what is prohibited leaves the member guessing and inadvertently undermines the guarantee that everyone is assumed innocent until proven guilty through objectively defined standards. The Court is adopting the "Vagueness Doctrine," wherein legislation is invalid if it's too unclear for a reasonable, ordinary person to understand.
WHEREFORE.-The Crimes (Amendment 2) Act 2026 is hereby declared UNCONSTITUTIONAL and shall not take effect.
SO ORDERED.-Senior Associate Justice Inconclusive- delivered the opinion in which Deputy Chief Justice Kelpti, Senior Associate Justice Brokyy_ and Associate Justices Andrew00., OllieSafe, .Martin and T-im joined.